Sunday 25 February, 2024

'Upland farms worse off' under current payment options

NFU modelling work showed on average upland farm businesses lost 37 per cent of their support payments under the current Sustainable Farming Incentive and Countryside Stewardship options

clock • 3 min read
'Upland farms worse off' under current payment options

Upland farm businesses will continue to be worse off under new support schemes unless the Government pulls a ‘rabbit out of the hat' and plugs the hole left by direct payments.

With upland farms playing a valuable role across rural communities, NFU uplands forum chair Thomas Binns has called for Government to act to bridge the current income gap and significant income loss faced by a range of upland farm businesses.

Upland farmers

The forum's modelling work, which used real data from upland farms, showed on average the businesses lost 37 per cent of their support payments under the current Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) and Countryside Stewardship (CS) options.

Mr Binns said the repeated commentary from the beginning of SFI delivery, had been that the Government valued and recognised the work of hill farms with upland farmers being told they would ‘not be worse off' in the transition from the Basic Payment Scheme.

NFU modelling 

But the modelling work done by the NFU, which worked with six case study farms to calculate the maximum theoretical SFI and CS earnings available for each farm, showed the disparity.

Read also:

Sustainable Farming Incentive: Weighing up the best options for grassland farms

Autumn Statement: What it means for farm businesses 

Mr Binns said: "Like all upland farmers, I love the hills I work in and I want to ensure that I can continue to produce food for the nation while leaving the countryside in a better state for the next generation." He said the union had been encouraging Defra to do its own modelling work, but this had never materialised.

Data from the NFU's work has been in Defra's inbox since September, Mr Binns added. The ‘final chapter' of SFI was expected to be announced imminently, but there were some concerns that it could be delayed, due to the reset expected after the recent appointment of Steve Barclay as Defra Secretary.

Grassland options

He hoped the next announcement would support calls for further grassland options, greater flexibility of stacking and premium payments for bundling, as well as improved accessibility to SFI for farmers signed up to existing schemes. 

With the clock ticking down for farm businesses, if the final stage failed to consider these, Mr Binns said he would request an Efra Inquiry to find out why Defra was not prepared to support what the modelling data shows. 

Improved payment rates and options

Jane Bassett, an upland farmer from Derbyshire said: "The financial gap which has been clearly identified needs to be closed and closed quickly for upland farmers." 

She called for an improved payment rates and options, perhaps bundles for grassland farmers along with the roll out of the moorland being standard to all. 

Defra

A Defra spokesperson acknowledged the role upland farmers played and said it was 'continuing to work closely with farmers and landowners'. 

The spokesperson said: " We have already increased payment rates under Countryside Stewardship and SFI to make sure that upland farmers are paid the same as lowland farmers for carrying out the same action." 

Kongskilde Delta 3000

Kongskilde Delta 3000

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

2020 CLAAS Direct Disc 500P Wholecrop Header

2020 CLAAS Direct Disc 500P Wholecrop Header

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

ENEGIS ROOT CHOPPERS & CLEANERS

ENEGIS ROOT CHOPPERS & CLEANERS

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Politics

Key takeaways from the NFU Conference

Key takeaways from the NFU Conference

More than 1,500 farmers attended the Conference at the International Convention Centre in Birmingham. What did farmers learn?

clock 24 February 2024 • 16 min read
Government criticised for failing to make sure support schemes help farmers

Government criticised for failing to make sure support schemes help farmers

Liberal Democrats MP Tim Farron said: "Landscape recovery has been tailored to reward big corporates who are evicting tenants."

clock 23 February 2024 • 2 min read
Farmers asked to donate old wellies for Senedd display to highlight SFS impact

Farmers asked to donate old wellies for Senedd display to highlight SFS impact

The display of 5,500 wellies will depict the 5,500 agricultural jobs that are predicted to be lost based on 100 per cent take up of the Sustainable Farming Scheme

clock 23 February 2024 • 2 min read