Farmers concerned stress of HS2 could have been 'for nothing'

Amid reports the Manchester leg of HS2 has been scrapped, affected farmers spoke out about the anxiety the project has caused

Chris Brayford
clock • 2 min read
Farmers concerned stress of HS2 could have been 'for nothing'

Talks of scrapping the Birmingham to Manchester section of HS2 mean affected farmers' anxiety over the past decade could have been ‘for nothing'.

According to reports from ITV News, the Manchester leg of HS2 has been shelved meaning the project will no longer go beyond Birmingham.

An extension of the HS2 line between Birmingham and Leeds was removed altogether in 2021.

HS2 scrapped

Michael Swerling, a beef and sheep farmer from Chalfont St Giles in the Chalfonts, said the development of the route between London and Birmingham through his family farm has not only placed a toll on their business, but had led to the destruction of relationships and the landscape.

Having also held a protest blocking workers' access to the farm in 2020 over compensation claims, Mr Swerling said the local countryside had been ‘picturesque' with flourishing wildlife and natural habitats, but was now a construction site.

See also: Gagging orders and spiralling mental health - true cost of HS2 revealed

"It has been very painful to see the destruction of our countryside for the sake of cutting journey times to London by a relatively small fraction," he said.

He added relationships with friends and family had also been affected with late compensation leaving ‘a sour taste'.

Family farm

"A farm which has been in our family for more than 70 years does not even feel like our own anymore and my dad Simon has been the one hurt by this most, because he has lived here all of his life and experienced the stress of planning and seeing his home destroyed," he said.

"If HS2 were to be scrapped, the nightmare we have had to face every single day since work began more than 10 years ago would have been for nothing.

From the editor: Stonewalling farmers is a recipe for disaster, not growth

"We will be left to pick up the pieces."

Home Office Minister Chris Philp said costs for HS2 had ‘tripled' since the idea was first conceived under David Cameron's Government.

Mr Philp added ‘no decisions' had yet been made about the remaining stages of HS2.

HS2 has been approached for further comment.

 

More on Farm Life

Kate Rowell: "It sent a signal that the Scottish Gov sees the red meat sector as an important part of the country's economy"

Kate Rowell: "It sent a signal that the Scottish Gov sees the red meat sector as an important part of the country's economy"

Scottish Borders farmer and QMS chair Kate Rowell on a successful Royal Highland Show and the positive messages from three key Ministers at the event

Kate Rowell
clock 05 July 2026 • 3 min read
Farming Matters: "In a densely populated and uncertain world, domestic food supply remains a critical priority"

Farming Matters: "In a densely populated and uncertain world, domestic food supply remains a critical priority"

Stephen Ramsden, a fourth-generation farm estate owner from North Yorkshire highlights the challenges and dilemmas faced by rural landowners

clock 04 July 2026 • 4 min read
Wallace Currie: "Agroecology has been quietly embedded within island life for generations"

Wallace Currie: "Agroecology has been quietly embedded within island life for generations"

Rural podcaster Wallace Currie recounts the journey he took around his home island the Isle of Arran for a new podcast series focusing on agroecology

clock 03 July 2026 • 6 min read