Monday 27 November, 2023

Letters: Sheep dip reality - 'the only effective way to combat this dreadful disease is sheep dip'

This week's letters from Farmers Guardian readers.

clock • 2 min read
Letters: Sheep dip reality - 'the only effective way to combat this dreadful disease is sheep dip'
AFTER reading Rachael Brown's article 'Welsh sheep dip disposal charges blow' (FG, July 7), I can only say how unjustified and appalling Martyn Evans and his Welsh Government quango, Natural Resources Wales (NRW), have treated Welsh farmers and the rural community. 
Increasing the sheep dip disposal permit fee from £402 to £3,728 is an abuse of NRW's monopoly status at a time of rampant inflation. No private business would be legally allowed to increase its charges tenfold. Yet Martyn Evans of NRW states that this was allowed after a consultation with the Welsh Government. 
I have news for him - as a taxpayer I fund his wages and also that of the Welsh Government. Sheep scab is a brutal endemic parasitic disease that virtually causes a sheep to scratch itself to death. The only effective way to combat this dreadful disease is sheep dip.
So why does NRW and the Welsh Government not consider the welfare of sheep and also that of the Welsh farming industry?
Many sheep owners have 50 or less ewes so to treat this awful condition would be unaffordable.
The true reality for attaining a permit for sheep dip disposal requires a site visit from one member of NRW staff who, after inspecting the watercourses then checks soil data on the computer (samples are generally not taken). 
Mr Martyn Evans should not exaggerate the expertise or time taken to complete the application which any competent person should be able to issue a permit in a few hours. How then does he justify £3,728?
Mr Evans should [perhaps learn a lesson in parasitology in that a good parasite will take sustenance from its host without destroying the host and hence any future sustenance.
John Jenkins, Pontarddulais, Swansea

FARM TO LET on behalf of The Duchy of Lancaster, Bagshaws LLP

FARM TO LET on behalf of The Duchy of Lancaster,

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

FOR SALE 5 BEDROOM DORMER BUNGALOW

FOR SALE 5 BEDROOM DORMER BUNGALOW

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Farm Life

Shaun and Peter

Selling direct gives new entrant couple business boost

One farming couple have managed to secure themselves a tenancy in Cornwall and found their market by selling direct. Ruth Wills finds out more

ruth wills
clock 24 November 2023 • 8 min read
Labour councillors have said eating meat harms the planet and people's health

Council meat rules likened to those of 'pork pie police'

Officials at Gloucestershire County Council hit back at proposals to reduce meat menu options

clock 24 November 2023 • 2 min read
Popular YouTube farmer Olly Harrison is considering a bid for the NFU leadership team

Farmers join forces to consider NFU leadership challenge

Social media farming favourites say it is time for 'real change' at the farming union

clock 23 November 2023 • 3 min read