Alistair Carmichael: "80 years of Government interference in the food market has hard-wired unfairness into it. It is Britain's farmers who have lost out as a result"

Mr Carmichael, chair of the Efra Committee, writes about the need to address the problem of low farm incomes, how his Food Supply Chain Fairness Bill could help shift the dial for farmers in getting a fair price for their produce, and the need to take on the supermarket giants and give back power to farmers

clock • 3 min read
Alistair Carmichael, Lib Dem MP for Orkney and Shetland, said: "'Asset rich, cash poor' has been the reality for farmers and crofters for decades...the question remains: what are we going to do about it?"
Image:

Alistair Carmichael, Lib Dem MP for Orkney and Shetland, said: "'Asset rich, cash poor' has been the reality for farmers and crofters for decades...the question remains: what are we going to do about it?"

Every cloud has a silver lining.

If there is one benefit that has come from the Government's Inheritance Tax raid on farms, it is surely the spotlight that has been placed on the meagre income that farmers actually make from their property.

For those already familiar with the smell of silage and slurry this has of course been no great revelation.

READ NOW: Wendy Chamberlain: "It feels like the odds are stacked against farmers at the moment"

'Asset rich, cash poor' has been the reality for farmers and crofters for decades.

Welcome though it is that people (if not the Government themselves) are starting to wake up to the poor wage paid to those who supply our country's food, the question remains: what are we going to do about it?

Answering that challenge fully would take more space than I have available today, so I am going to focus on just one element – getting a fairer deal for farmers and a fairer price for their product.

That is why next Wednesday (March 19) I will be introducing the Food Supply Chain Fairness Bill in Parliament.

PLEDGE YOUR SUPPORT: Join Farmers Guardian's Save Britain's Family Farms campaign

I have been ploughing this particular furrow (if you will forgive the pun) for some years already, though taking on the Chair of the House of Commons Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Select Committee has given me more scope to zero-in on the problem.

Well-meaning or not, 80 years of Government interference in the food market has hard-wired unfairness into it.

It is Britain's farmers who have lost out as a result.

We all know the problems in getting fairer farmgate prices.

Food supply chain fairness is about supporting farmers but we should not allow it to be portrayed as a problem for consumers.

SIGN THE PETITION: Embed food, farming, and sustainability education into the national curriculum

For decades the major supermarkets have taken advantage of their market dominance to drive hard bargains with food producers, drive down input costs and drive up their profits.

All this has been done in the name of 'cheap' food, but somehow cheap food still involves inflated profits for supermarkets.

You do not have to be Albert Einstein to work out who loses out in that equation.

Market regulation is still a fairly recent phenomenon in the food supply chain.

It is still only twelve years since the Groceries Code Adjudicator (GCA) was set up.

LISTEN NOW:

Since then the Agriculture Act of 2020 has imposed another layer of regulation to the heap, but nothing is joined up and the outcomes for farmers do not seem to be much better than before.

The establishment of the GCA was an important first step but I do not think anyone thought it would be the last word.

Now is the time to beef up its remit – and more besides.

We need to give the GCA meaningful resources and the regulatory muscle it needs to act, and to strengthen the hand of farmers and food producers.

I know that these are areas of significant interest for the farming unions and other rural organisations such as the Countryside Alliance and CLA, and I have been glad to take their advice and support in developing the plan that I am bringing forward next week.

I hope that the Government will engage with this Bill constructively to deliver on these goals – and I would strongly encourage you to reach out to your local MP and tell them to back the Bill when it comes to Parliament on Wednesday (March 19).

With enough support, this could be the opportunity – a start at least – for the Government to craft a silver lining to the dark cloud they have created for themselves, and reset their relationship with farmers.

READ NOW: Tim Farron: "I cannot remember a time when farmers were treated so badly by those in power"

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

FARM LOANS & RE-MORTGAGES

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit Sales

BNG National Habitat Bank Creation & Unit

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

WATER ABSTRACTION LICENCES FOR SALE

WATER ABSTRACTION LICENCES FOR SALE

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Politics

Sustainable farming and food production must be at heart of next Welsh Government, says FUW

Sustainable farming and food production must be at heart of next Welsh Government, says FUW

Union unveils its Senedd Election Manifesto asking politicians to provide stability and long-term support

clock 15 September 2025 • 2 min read
From the editor: Musical chairs at Defra - Can Emma Reynolds rise to the challenge?

From the editor: Musical chairs at Defra - Can Emma Reynolds rise to the challenge?

This week from Farmers Guardian editor Katie Jones

clock 11 September 2025 • 2 min read
EXCLUSIVE - Andrew RT Davies: "Livestock farming in Wales is approaching a crisis point"

EXCLUSIVE - Andrew RT Davies: "Livestock farming in Wales is approaching a crisis point"

South Wales Central MS Andrew RT Davies writes on the Climate Change Committee's report on reducing livestock numbers, bluetongue, NVZs, bovine TB and the Sustainable Farming Scheme

Andrew RT Davies
clock 11 September 2025 • 4 min read