85% of farmers oppose white-tailed eagle reintroduction, NFU survey reveals

An NFU survey of farmers and land managers in Cumbria, North Yorkshire and Durham has revealed significant opposition to the reintroduction of white‑tailed eagles, with 85% of respondents against the proposal. It comes following concern from NFU members and the wider farming community about the proposed reintroduction of white-tailed eagles and the impacts it will have on livestock welfare and the long-term future of upland farming. READ MORE: NSA members bring sheep farming into the classroom The findings highlighted significant concern within the farming community about the consequences of re-introducing a large apex predator into working landscapes where sheep farming underpins local economies, environmental stewardship and cultural heritage. Without robust evidence, properly funded mitigation measures and clear long‑term management plans, farmers fear the costs and consequences of reintroduction would fall disproportionately on them. NFU North regional board chair William Maughan said: "Farmers are not opposed to nature recovery, but it must work alongside productive agriculture, not undermine it. "The survey shows serious reservations about how livestock welfare would be protected and who would bear the long‑term responsibility if problems arise." Farmers also highlighted the practical challenges of managing sheep in extensive upland farms, where close monitoring is often impossible, and warned that reintroduction could significantly increase labour demands, costs and mental wellbeing pressures. 58% of farmers who completed the survey were unaware of the project at all, which NFU environment adviser Abigail Teward says is extremely concerning. "This is particularly worrying given that a longstanding NFU position is that any reintroduction programme must involve early, meaningful and transparent consultation from organisations with the farming community," she said. "With 85% of respondents opposing reintroduction, farmers are clearly telling us they are deeply concerned about what this would mean for their animals, their livelihoods and the future of upland farming in Cumbria. "These concerns are grounded in evidence gained from feedback from farmers in Scotland where white-tailed eagles have been reintroduced and other parts of the UK and should not be dismissed. Any decision must fully recognise the risks farmers believe they will be asked to shoulder." A Defra spokesperson said: "We are backing sheep farmers and want a productive, profitable and sustainable future for farming that will go hand in hand with restoring our most threatened native wildlife.

Agriculture's National Classifieds

85% of farmers oppose white-tailed eagle reintroduction, NFU survey reveals

Concerns within the farming community about the consequences of re-introducing the large apex predator were highlighted in the survey

Already a member? Login for full access.

More on Animal Health

Bluetongue latest: Confirmed cases top 3,000 | Bluetongue will persist over the winter

Farmers urged to plan for bluetongue 2027 as cases in Wales hit 500

Meat sector body urges Gov to delay pig stunning consultation until SPS deal signed

Agriculture's National Classifieds

New and Used Farm Machinery

Farm Equipment

Livestock

Farm Property for Sale

85% of farmers oppose white-tailed eagle reintroduction, NFU survey reveals

Concerns within the farming community about the consequences of re-introducing the large apex predator were highlighted in the survey

Share

Already a member? Login for full access.

Previous Article

Next Article

More on Animal Health

Bluetongue latest: Confirmed cases top 3,000 | Bluetongue will persist over the winter

Farmers urged to plan for bluetongue 2027 as cases in Wales hit 500

Meat sector body urges Gov to delay pig stunning consultation until SPS deal signed