Sheep farmer James Rebanks turns down Defra role invite: "I cannot be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strongly believe ought to be kept"

Cumbrian sheep farmer and author James Rebanks reflects on his decision to turn down the invite to apply for a non-executive director at Defra

clock • 1 min read
Sheep farmer James Rebanks turns down Defra role invite: "I cannot be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strongly believe ought to be kept"

Cumbrian sheep farmer and author James Rebanks has turned down the invitation from Defra to apply for a non-executive director role at the Government department. 

By James Rebanks


"[I am] grateful to be asked, and that anyone there thinks I might be as asset. But as I said in my reply, I can't be complicit in the breaking of promises to farmers that I strong believe ought to be kept.

Defra

"As I tweeted last week, there is a shifting away from big commitments that I find deeply problematic. The level of budget declining. The chance of transition for most farms vanishing. The shift from public commitments to dodgy corporate money when we need more done and quick.

READ MORE: Financial consequences of bluetongue restrictions could see Suffolk farmer £50,000 out of pocket

"With those trends continuing and no commitment to do better, I can't sit round a table and act like it's OK. I'll happily help for free to make things work better, but I'm not prepared to be window dressing for decline and failure.

'Drifting away from us'

"And for the first time in my life I nearly said yes. I think we are within touching distance of a much better system and much better landscapes - but it's drifting away from us by the week.

READ ALSO: Defra's £358 million underspend of agriculture budget 'kick in the teeth' for farmers

"But a board member is partly responsible for what's done. So you have to believe you'd get a decent hearing and a chance of impact. Otherwise I may as well stay independent and be a mostly constructive critic."

 

 

More on Blogs

Opinion: A farming minister who knows about farming? Now there's a thought...

Opinion: A farming minister who knows about farming? Now there's a thought...

The new Plaid Cymru Government was certainly feeling the love at this year's Royal Welsh Show

Jane Thynne
clock 23 July 2026 • 3 min read
Farming Matters: Burnham's farming test will be SPS, not slogans

Farming Matters: Burnham's farming test will be SPS, not slogans

Graeme Taylor, founder and chief executive at Endure Consulting, says the incoming Prime Minister must do the right thing by farmers when it comes to the EU reset

Graeme Taylor
clock 18 July 2026 • 3 min read
Opinion: England's semi-final heartbreak shows why winning isn't always enough – just ask Keir Starmer

Opinion: England's semi-final heartbreak shows why winning isn't always enough – just ask Keir Starmer

But will a change at the top bring real change or just more unnecessary upheaval at Defra

Jane Thynne
clock 16 July 2026 • 3 min read