Pensioner wins 'landmark' case to halt Ed Miliband's solar 'revolution' on prime agricultural land

78-year-old retired scientist Chala Fiske has won a seven-year battle with Test Valley Borough Council to stop a solar farm from being built on farm land. She said the land would be better suited for agriculture than a solar development

Chris Brayford
clock • 4 min read
Chala Fiske, a Hampshire pensioner, said: "The problem I had with it is this country cannot provide its own food. We have got about 40% food security and if we have the war, and we are close to a war, we just will not be able to do anything. We know we cannot even fight a war, so food security on an island is very, very important, it really is. I am not against the solar farm so much, I am against it because it is on good land."
Image:

Chala Fiske, a Hampshire pensioner, said: "The problem I had with it is this country cannot provide its own food. We have got about 40% food security and if we have the war, and we are close to a war, we just will not be able to do anything. We know we cannot even fight a war, so food security on an island is very, very important, it really is. I am not against the solar farm so much, I am against it because it is on good land."

A 'landmark' ruling in Hampshire has dented Ed Miliband's plans to build solar farms on agricultural land. Chala Fiske won a seven-year battle with Test Valley Borough Council (TVBC) last month to halt...

To continue reading...

Already a member? Login for full access.

Login

New to Farmers Guardian? Register for 1 free article per week or become a member for unlimited access to essential farming news and insights.

article-img-580x358
Register for free Join Now

 

More on Farm Business

From the editor: LAMMA was the ultimate showcase of resilience and an industry driving change
Farm Business

From the editor: LAMMA was the ultimate showcase of resilience and an industry driving change

This week from Farmers Guardian editor Katie Jones

Katie Jones
Katie Jones
clock 15 January 2026 • 2 min read
Farmers must be consulted on future Manchester to Birmingham rail link
Farm Business

Farmers must be consulted on future Manchester to Birmingham rail link

NFU says farm businesses will suffer if 'chaotic' HS2 is repeated

Jane Thynne
clock 15 January 2026 • 2 min read
British farmers 'more likely' to profit from improving the environment rather than producing food, study reveals
Farm Business

British farmers 'more likely' to profit from improving the environment rather than producing food, study reveals

Producing food for the nation feels like a vocation for so many UK farmers. But is their fundamental role as food growers being undermined by an overreliance to support the environment if it is the only way they can earn a profit?

Chris Brayford
Chris Brayford
clock 14 January 2026 • 2 min read