Framing SFI closure as a triumph added 'insult to injury', says Efra chair

The Government has pulled the rug out from under farmers across England, according to Alastair Carmichael

Chris Brayford
clock • 4 min read
Lib Dem MP Alistair Carmichael said: "The decision to close SFI on Tuesday (March 11) without any notice has provoked predictable and justifiable fury, but doing it with a press release that sought to present it as some sort of triumph added insult to injury. It was almost like a return to the glory days of the Soviet Union, when the Politburo would boast about their advances in meeting their targets in the five-year plan for tractor production."
Image:

Lib Dem MP Alistair Carmichael said: "The decision to close SFI on Tuesday (March 11) without any notice has provoked predictable and justifiable fury, but doing it with a press release that sought to present it as some sort of triumph added insult to injury. It was almost like a return to the glory days of the Soviet Union, when the Politburo would boast about their advances in meeting their targets in the five-year plan for tractor production."

Efra Committee Chair Alastair Carmichael has criticised the tone of language used by Defra to announce its closure of Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) applications for farmers seeking to benefit nature,...

To continue reading...

Already a member? Login for full access.

Login

New to Farmers Guardian? Register for 1 free article per week or become a member for unlimited access to essential farming news and insights.

article-img-580x358

 

McHALE INTEGRATED BALER

McHALE INTEGRATED BALER

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

NEW Strickworth 3 Ton Diesel Forklift Trucks

NEW Strickworth 3 Ton Diesel Forklift Trucks

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

2018 KRAMER KL30.5T

2018 KRAMER KL30.5T

VIEW ADVERT
£POA

More on Politics

Elderly farmers who helped to rebuild Britain after WW2 'trapped' by IHT changes

Elderly farmers who helped to rebuild Britain after WW2 'trapped' by IHT changes

Is this the right way to treat a generation of farmers and business owners who fed a nation during conflict and rebuilt the country from the rubble of war?

Chris Brayford
clock 31 October 2025 • 4 min read
UFU executive vote confirms no confidence in DAERA

UFU executive vote confirms no confidence in DAERA

The Ulster Farmers’ Union said it represented a ‘deep dissatisfaction’ with the department

Alex Black
clock 31 October 2025 • 2 min read
OPINION: "Is the Government seriously asking farmers to cover less than 0.5% of the UK's annual debt interest bill?"

OPINION: "Is the Government seriously asking farmers to cover less than 0.5% of the UK's annual debt interest bill?"

Farmers Guardian’s Tom Ryder, hailing from a Cumbria-based family with a history in pedigree livestock breeding, reflects on how the Government’s proposed Inheritance Tax reforms risk overlooking the human realities behind the numbers

clock 30 October 2025 • 3 min read