Farming Union calls for Welsh Government to publish SFS consultation analysis sooner

NFU Cymru president, Aled Jones said whilst he applauded Welsh Government's 'ambitious' time frame, he was resistant to launching an SFS scheme that was 'not ready', adding he felt there was a lack of comprehension on ‘the enormity' of what is still left to be done, including piloting and an up-to-date impact assessment

Rachael Brown
Chief Reporter
clock • 2 min read
Farming Union calls for Welsh Government to publish SFS consultation analysis sooner

The Welsh Government cannot afford to wait until the beginning of May to publish their report on the Sustainable Farming Scheme (SFS) consultation responses, if they still want to launch SFS in January 2025.

Welsh agriculture

That was the message from NFU Cymru president, Aled Jones at the union's first meeting with both the new First Minister Vaughan Gething and his newly appointed Cabinet Secretary for Climate Change and Rural Affairs, Huw Irranca-Davies MS. 

See also: Welsh lamb receives 'top marks' from consumers in Japan

Mr Jones said whilst he applauded Welsh Government's 'ambitious' time frame, he was 'resistant to launching an SFS scheme that was 'not ready', adding he felt there was a lack of comprehension on ‘the enormity' of what is still left to be done with SFS, including piloting and an up-to-date impact assessment. 

The appointment of Mr Davies has on the whole has been positively received, with a feeling that he was a 'good choice' out of those rumoured for the job at the time. Farmers and union leaders recognised his wealth of experience, and a familiar industry face, having served as a former Shadow Defra Minister.

See also: Managing business change in dairy farming

Sustainable Farming Scheme

Mr Jones acknowledged whilst many would instead 'look for a place to hide', given the 'anger and fear' out there in the industry, Mr Davies said to him in the meeting that he was 'chuffed to bits' to get the role and that he was determined to get the industry to a position that it can work with.

But Mr Jones said he did not want to 'expand hope beyond what it is' right now, and that there were no 'tangible actions' yet to judge the new team on.

Welsh Government

Mr Jones reiterated in the meeting that farmers feel 'disengaged' with Welsh Government, adding if they wanted to restore relationships they must demonstrate that they are listening. 

"They didn't say anything, but from their facial expressions, you could tell that they understood what I was telling them." 

See also: Red Tractor axes Greener Farms Commitment module

The NFU Cymru president said Mr Davies told him that he 'did not want any surprises'. 

Mr Jones believed that indicated a will to move forward into the role with better understanding, 'so we do not have flare ups that we have seen in the last few months.'

More on Politics

Defra urged by Labour MPs to boost drought resilience for farms

Defra urged by Labour MPs to boost drought resilience for farms

Norfolk's Ben Goldsborough leads call for more reservoirs, better communication and flexible abstraction rights

Jane Thynne
clock 01 August 2026 • 2 min read
Government faces backlash over peatland wildfire policy

Government faces backlash over peatland wildfire policy

The Countryside Alliance has accused the UK government of worsening wildfire risks by continuing to ban heather burning on deep peat

Rachael Brown
clock 30 July 2026 • 2 min read
Opinion: Liz Staley - Ensuring farming support reaches farmers and delivers value for taxpayers

Opinion: Liz Staley - Ensuring farming support reaches farmers and delivers value for taxpayers

Cumbrian farmer Liz Staley reflects on the Sustainable Farming Incentive

Liz Staley
clock 25 July 2026 • 4 min read