Date is set for hearing into Defra’s proposed badger culls

THE Badger Trust’s judicial review of Defra’s decision to allow badger culls to take place in England this autumn has been set for Monday, June 25 and Tuesday, June 26.

The case will be heard in the High Court in London, where the trust will ask the court to overturn Defra’s decision to sanction pilot culls in West Gloucestershire and West Somerset.

If the judge backs its case, the policy could be delayed, or even scuppered altogether.

The Badger Trust’s judicial review of the Welsh Assembly Government’s decision to cull badgers in north Pembrokeshire succeeded on all grounds in the Court of Appeal in 2010, initially delaying the policy, before the Welsh administration finally abandoned it this year.

The trust said it considered culling ‘would not prevent the spread of disease but rather make matters worse, at great cost to farmers, the taxpayer and badgers’.

Gwendolen Morgan of Bindmans LLP, the trust’s solicitor said: “We have identified some serious flaws in the way by which the Secretary of State reached her decision to cull badgers.

Struck down

“Given Defra’s proposals come at an enormous cost to farmers, and threaten to prompt, rather than prevent the spread of disease, we hope this ill-conceived decision will be struck down by the court.”

At last week’s Beef Expo 2012 event in Malvern, NBA TB committee chairman and South West farmer Bill Harper was adamant the cull would still go ahead.

He described TB as a ‘fire which is spreading ever outwards’ and needed tackling from a range of angles.

Mr Harper said: “I bet money we will win the judicial review. We have learned from the Welsh and will not make the same mistakes as them.”

He said the next step was to investigate ways of ‘badger euthanasia’, the main one being to fill the setts with gas filled foam to eradicate the diseased animals.

Readers' comments (4)

  • Time to scrap all these ridiculous laws and allow common sense to prevail once again.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • The 1970's zuckerman report into badgers and TB found that using cyanide gas to kill badgers was inhumane as the animals took many hours to die inderground. The use of gas was transferred from rabbit control, but rabbits have a faster metabolic rate, and inhale the gas far quicker than badgers. Gas filled foam would be the same as tipping oads of slurry into badger setts in terms of humane euthanasia.
    Rabies has and is being eradicated across Europe by using an oral vaccine in baits targetted at the main wildlife vector, in this case the red fox. Vaccination, initally of badgers, but aiming for EU approval for cattle vaccine is what's needed long term.
    NB France has such an enviably low rate of bTB because they don't look for it...

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • "Exasperated Me" is certainly exasperating me!
    His version of common sense is forget the science, just kill.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • 1. Rabies is a virus, TB is a bacterium
    2. France deals with infected wildlife.

    Dianne Summers had been vaccinated with BCG - note her predicament as it will be repeated yet many times over if nothing is done.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

Register your email address for Farmers Guardian e-bulletins

Get the latest from Farmers Guardian delivered straight to your inbox. Click here to sign-up today

Already receiving bulletins? Sign-in to edit your preferences