Government faces legal challenge over battery egg imports

THE British egg industry is set to challenge Defra in the courts over its refusal to ban imports of illegally-produced battery cage eggs and egg products. 

The British Egg Industry Council (BEIC) has embarked on the first stage towards launching Judicial Review proceedings by formally writing to Defra to challenge the UK Government on its response to the EU battery cage ban, which came into force on January 1.

British egg producers have invested £400 million phasing out battery cages to meet the requirements of the new EU legislation and all British Lion cage eggs now come from ‘enriched colony’ cages.  

However producers in 13 other EU countries, including Spain, Italy and Poland, have not fully complied with the ban. It is estimated that around one-quarter of EU cage egg production is still illegal, with more than 50 million hens still being kept in battery cages, producing more than 40 million eggs a day.

In December, Farming Minister Jim Paice announced that the UK would not impose a unilateral ban on eggs produced in battery cages, citing ‘very significant legal and financial implications’ and practical difficulties in enforcing such a ban.

Instead the UK is relying on ultra-violet testing of imported shell eggs and a voluntary food industry ban, backed by a number of retailers, food service companies, manufacturers and processors.

The BEIC said its legal advice was that the Government has ‘incorrectly interpreted the law’ and suggested it was ‘condoning the importation of illegal battery cage eggs and egg products into the UK’.

The council’s ‘pre-action protocol letter’ asks Defra to give a fuller explanation for its decision and to review its current position that the Government cannot do anything to prevent the importation of illegally produced eggs and egg products. 

BEIC chairman Andrew Parker said: “British egg producers have invested heavily to meet their legal obligations and improve animal welfare. 

“We now need our Government to support them by preventing unfair competition from producers in other countries who have not complied with the ban.”

He said it was ‘ridiculous’  that while the  Government has said it will check shell egg imports, it does not plan to check imported egg products or products containing eggs.  

He insisted this was a ‘standard traceability procedure operated throughout the food industry both here in the UK and in the EU’ and a ‘straightforward process for the Government’.

“We’re asking the Government to conduct proper checks of imported eggs, egg products and products containing eggs entering UK ports, egg packing stations, processing plants, importers and wholesalers.  Otherwise, UK consumers could be eating eggs from illegal battery hens, and British egg producers will be seriously undermined, with the possible loss of thousands of jobs,” he said.

A Defra spokesperson said: “Given the very significant legal and financial implications of introducing such a ban, coupled with practical difficulties in enforcing it, it is not a realistic option.

“To protect consumers from buying eggs from battery cages we have worked closely with the major food processors and retailers who have agreed not to supply these eggs or use them in their own foods.”

  • The BEIC has launched a new website - www.legaleggs.com - and is calling for food companies and the public to sign its pledge to support British egg producers and help keep illegal eggs out of the UK.

Readers' comments (7)

  • Other EU countries ignore half of the rules and regulations they don't like, and usually get away with it. The UK government insists on imposing them to the letter and consequently this leads to unsustainable demands on many businesses with obvious implications for profitability and therefore, jobs. Come on government, stand up for those doing the job in your own country for once!

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Voluntary codes ? -as usual the UK Government tries to chicken out ! . Ignoring its own industry and the welfare of chickens. Go for it BEIC !

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Taking the quota expirience of dairy farmers. Italy ignored them for years and pig farmers "leading the world on welfare" according to blair with the stalls ban I'm afraid I sincerely wish the poultry men good luck. Taking this history into account you WILL need it

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Has every egg producer n the UK been inspected for compliance? If so can we not insist that this procedure is followed abroad. If it's not practical to inspect egg products for compliance at import then it needs to be done at source.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • MR CAMERON.and his team has no regard british farmers. other countries do what they want. and that suites mr cameron hold down the british farmer. letters of treaths to 13 other countries means nothing. they reply tesco like our very low price. asda like very low price. morrision like very low price. waiterose like our very low price. so why you complaim our price very low. we have small hen in small box no need for BIG BOX. OUR SMALL HEN LAY BIG EGG. SO WHY YOU COMPLAIN. MR CAMRON NOT COMPLAIN HE WORK WITH STORES STORES LIKE LOW PRICE

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • One may note that Jim Paice's own farming interests do not derive an income from eggs.

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

  • Lets boycott the shops and supermarkets selling EU eggs for starters.....

    Unsuitable or offensive? Report this comment

Have your say

Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory
Mandatory
Register your email address for Farmers Guardian e-bulletins

Get the latest from Farmers Guardian delivered straight to your inbox. Click here to sign-up today

Already receiving bulletins? Sign-in to edit your preferences